–Brian Sabean, GM of the San Francisco Giants,
signed Edgar Renteria on December 3rd 2008, and now, 28 days later, I assess
the damage. A while back, I wrote off Sabean as the worst GM in baseball. Although I’ve switched positions since then, Sabean is showing why he has
always been in my bottom five.
The Mike Jacobs trade was
bad. Raul Ibanez and A.J. Burnett got
overpaid, and the Kyle Farnsworth signing was just stupid, but the worst deal
made this off-season is undoubtedly the Edgar Renteria
signing. Forget the fact the Giants
already had a young, worthy shortstop, and forget the fact the Giants are in
rebuilding mode. Renteria just got flat
His hitting has
deteriorated; he has no range, and is 33 years old. Why on earth would a GM sign him to a two-year contract worth
$18MM? Since that’s too much money to
be an “insurance” player in case Manny Burriss
doesn’t perform, Renteria is going to be playing every day.
Now, if Brian Sabean had
serious doubts about Manny Burriss being ready to play in the bigs, then I
would have respected his decision to sign a veteran free agent shortstop,
because I hate it when teams rush their prospects (hello J.R. Towles). I’m not saying Manny Burriss or Ivan Ochoa
aren’t ready, but if the Giants signed a consistent, inexpensive shortstop like
Berroa I would not have disagreed.
But Renteria is way too expensive, and was signed to a multi-year
deal. Seriously, what is Brian Sabean
thinking? I hope his plan isn’t to wait
for Renteria to have a comeback year and then trade him away for prospects
because Renteria will never have an OBP higher than .350 ever again, his range
is gone, and his power will only get worse in spacious AT&T Park.
I hope Edgar Renteria
realizes how lucky he is. I struggle to
find a single team that would have given him half the contract he signed for
with San Francisco.
The only way San Francisco
could screw up their situation more is if they keep Manny Burriss in the majors
as a backup. Because the only
silver lining in this signing is the chance Manny Burriss would have bombed in
the majors. This signing gets rid of
that risk. Perhaps he can develop
better in Triple-A Fresno rather than with the Giants. But still, Ivan Ochoa could’ve filled in for
Burriss. Besides, Renteria is signed
until 2011, and it won’t take that long for Burriss to develop. That is why this deal is so idiotic.
So now I present to you my list of the ten worst current general managers:
(Only counting time with their current club)
10. Ruben Amaro Jr. – PHI (He’s really only made one move, but it was bad)
9. J.P. Ricciardi – TOR
8. Dave Dombrowski – DET
7. Ed Wade – HOU
6. Kevin Towers – SD
5. Frank Wren – ATL
4. Brian Sabean – SF
3. Jim Bowden – WASH
2. Walt Jocketty – CIN
1. Dayton Moore – KC
Unless you are an intense
San Francisco baseball fan, or a just a crazy baseball super-fan, then you will
not recognize even half of the players above.
So here is who they are with the positions that they are capable of
playing adequately in the major leagues in parentheses: (starting with the
upper left, and going clockwise):
Burriss (SS, 2B)
(3B, 1B, C)
So what’s the point of
this long list? The main point is to show the many choices facing the Giants in selecting a starting second baseman, third baseman, and shortstop in
2009. Another important issue is who
deserves the title of “[insert infield position] of the future.” So, let’s just go through all of the young
players in the Giants organization who can play the infield. With all but one of the players capable of
playing multiple positions, it could get a bit confusing…
Brian Bocock Age: 24 Positions: SS, 2B
The only reason I talk
about Bocock is because he was the Opening Day shortstop for this team. And the only reason he got to hold that
honor is 1) Omar Vizquel got injured and 2) the Giants had nobody else. If everything went according to plan, Bocock
probably would have spent all of last year at San Jose (A+) or Connecticut
(AA). Unfortunately Bocock was rushed
(a lot) to the bigs and, as you might have guessed, he struggled mightily.
After Vizquel came back, he was sent
down. And then, typical of struggling
player, Bocock got injured and missed much of the year. Bocock only projects to be a utility
infielder and pinch runner. Although
his 2008 can’t be taken seriously because he was rushed so much, Bocock
doesn’t deserve to be considered as the shortstop or second baseman of the
future for the Giants.
Manny Burriss Age: 24 Positions:
I try not to be biased on
this blog, but Manny is one of my favorite players. He’s extremely friendly to fans and is the first D.C. public high
school product to be drafted and make it to the majors in 38 years. All bias aside though, Burriss is the
Giants shortstop of the future.
being promoted through the minor leagues at an astonishing rate, he somehow hit
well in the majors this year. How fast
was Burriss rushed? He had a .237 OBP
and .417 OPS in Class A Advanced last year (139 AB), and yet the Giants decided
he should skip Double-A. Then,
they called him to the majors after he only played 14 games in Triple-A
with a .281 OBP. Does the fact he
struggled in the minors make it a more likely scenario that he will have a
sophomore slump? Yeah, probably. But what else can you do? 240 at-bats are enough to show whether or
not a player is ready for The Show.
Even if Burriss struggles, he has the talent to be considered the
shortstop in San Francisco for a long time.
Kevin Frandsen Age: 26 Positions: 3B, 2B
Kevin Frandsen (the guy
who hit the BP ball that smacked
Barry Bonds in the head) just needs to stay healthy. He’s crushed AAA pitching, but never can play consistently in the
majors. If you pick up all of his big
league games combined, his numbers are not that impressive. But, considering how he handled the minors,
Frandsen should be given the opportunity to start every day at third base in
2009. It would be hypocritical for the
Giants to mistreat Frandsen, a true “gamer”, when playing hard everyday for 162
games is part of the Giants marketing theme. In fact, the Giants front office has
released a whole series of commercials asking players what defines a
gamer. He also had a .392 OBP in the
Arizona Fall League for what’s it worth.
(FYI, he was the oldest player there)
Connor Gillaspie Age: 21 Positions: 3B
Like Bocock, the only
reason Gillaspie is being mentioned in this list is because the Giants rushed
him and he was playing way out of his league (although, to his credit, he had
.429 OBP in 8 games.) Simply put,
Gillaspie doesn’t stand a chance to be the Giants’ third baseman next year. However, with a good year in San Jose (A+)
or Connecticut (AA), he is likely to, at some point, move Frandsen into a
super-utility role and earn the honor of the title “third baseman of the
future.” It will be interesting to see
what Gillaspie does next year on the farm, but he will have to prove he is more
valuable than Kevin Frandsen or Ryan Rohlinger. Expectations will be high, as he was drafted 37th
overall this year.
Ryan Rohlinger Age: 25 Positions: 3B, 2B
Rohlinger could be ready
for the big leagues right now, but the problem is that: 1) he hasn’t proven
himself at AAA, and 2) he’s hardly played second base in his career. With Burriss starting at short, and Frandsen
at third, Rohlinger will have to adjust to second base if he wants to start
next year for San Francisco. But since
the Giants have other second base options that have already proven themselves
at Triple-A, I’d let Rohlinger start the season in Fresno to learn second base
and of course see how well he will hit.
Rohlinger may end up being a utility player next year, but then again,
so could the other second base options like Frandsen, Velez, or Ochoa. Let’s just say Rohlinger lights it up in
Triple-A Fresno to start the year but Frandsen is doing well in the majors as
well. In that case Frandsen could move
over to second base (and kick out Velez or Ochoa), and Rohlinger would be able
to play his natural position at third.
As a general matter, Rohlinger’s future depends a lot on what the
players ahead of him do, since he isn’t quite as advanced as the rest (besides
Eugenio Velez Age: 26 Positions: LF, 2B
Velez is an interesting
player. This year in Fresno, he was one
of the best leadoff men in the Pacific Coast League (.881 OPS, 42 games). But when Velez played for the Giants, he
flat out stunk, even with a good September (.367 OBP). Playing in San Fran, Velez will always have
someone right behind to take over if he slumps. He is at the age (26) where he needs to put together a good full
season in the majors or forever be considered a career utility man and pinch
runner. Personally, my prediction for
Velez would be just that, a utility guy (he plays infield and outfield), and a
super-fast guy off the bench. Bruce
Bochy should give Velez the starting job at second base next year, but I truly
doubt Velez will be good enough to stop Ivan Ochoa or Ryan Rohlinger from
getting some time at 2B.
give S.F. his 50 stolen bases and four home runs a season, but the question is
whether he’s a .310 or .350 on-base guy.
I’d guess somewhere in the middle, but I’m not sure that is good enough.
Ivan Ochoa Age: 26 Positions: SS, 2B
Ivan Ochoa’s season was
very simple. He crushed in Triple-A,
and got crushed in the majors.
Is it worth giving him another shot?
Of course! He’s only 26 years
old and it was his rookie season after all.
But, I wouldn’t expect him to put up anything close to his numbers in
Fresno. I don’t think playing in the
hitter-friendly Pacific Coast League was the entire reason Ochoa’s power
suddenly flew up, but it’s worth noting that Ochoa’s slugging percentage never
was above .339 before hitting in the PCL.
He most likely projects to be a back up in the major leagues, but he’s
shown he can slug. He plays both middle
infield positions, but has spent more time at short on the farm. A key indicator of Ochoa’s future/career
will be where the Giants send him out of Spring Training next year. Here are his options:
Option 1 (Likely): Giants
utility infielder – The worst-case scenario for his career. This means Bruce Bochy and Brian Sabean see
Ochoa’s future as nothing more than as a utility player.
Option 2 (Possible):
Fresno’s starting shortstop – The Giants think highly enough of Ochoa to let
him get regular at-bats and only call him up if he can get significant playing
Option 3 (Unlikely):
Giants’ starting second baseman – The Giants really think highly of
Ochoa and are confident he is better than Ryan Rohlinger or Eugenio Velez. Based on Ochoa’s performance in every level
besides Triple-A, his chances look slim.
Pablo Sandoval Age: 22 Positions: 1B, 3B, C
Sandoval is basically
guaranteed a spot with the Giants next year after crushing in his 35-game stint
there and continuing his hot hitting in the Venezuelan Winter League where he
had a 1.119 OPS in 48 games. The
question is where he will play next season.
In order of games played, he is a first baseman, catcher, and third
baseman. In a perfect world I guess
Sandoval would be a first-baseman, but with the Giants, his best fit is behind
the plate. Benjie Molina is in the last
year of his contract and needs to be traded right now. After trading Molina (which is probably
easier said than done), Sandoval could slide in to be the everyday backstop and
attempt to replicate his breakout ’08 season.
My Picks for 2009
If I was Bruce Bochy,
these would be my picks for who would start at each infield position heading
into next season, and the people that would slide in if the starters are
injured or slump badly:
2B: Eugenio Velez (Kevin
SS: Manny Burriss (Ivan
3B: Kevin Frandsen (Ryan
I know I didn’t discuss
Travis Ishikawa or John Bowker in this post, but Bowker should start next year
in AAA, and should only be called up to the majors if he can get regular
at-bats. His 2007 season in Double-A cannot
be overlooked; he has some nice upside.
The Giants have a lot of
variables in the infield at this point, but a lot of uncertainty. I think Matt Downs
will provide stability at second base by 2010 or ’11.
And on a final note, I
have a very bold prediction: The San
Jose Giants will win the MILBY award (Minor League Baseball of the Year) for
“Team of the Year”. That award goes to
the most dominant team in all of the minors.
How could I pick one team out of all of the affiliated teams in
professional baseball? Well, it’s
The players on schedule
to play for San Jose next year have played on the “Team of the Year” the past
two seasons. In 2007, the Class A-Short
Season Salem-Keizer Volcanoes won Team of the Year. Then, most the same players went to play in Augusta, GA for the
Green Jackets. Guess what? That team was the 2008 Team of the
Year. See my logic? I guess there is this one wave of players
drafted by S.F. in 2007 that just knows how to win. It can’t hurt that ’08 Augusta manager Andy
Skeels is moving up to San Jose with his players. Players like Angel
Loree, and Wendell
Fairley may all start next year playing in High A. Just imagine how great that team would be if
the Giants didn’t decide to allow Tim
Alderson to skip Class A (by the way, smart move Fred
If it isn’t obvious
already, I wrote most of this entry before stupid Brian Sabean signed Edgar Renteria. But I’m stubborn and couldn’t let all this
writing go to waste.
I’m not about to claim I feel as bad as this guy, but I was
pretty ticked when I heard the Renteria news.
Nationals trade Austin Kearns to the Phillies for LHP Moises Melendez
a lot of “ifs” in this trade. This deal
only makes sense if the Phillies fail to re-sign Pat Burrell, and if
Washington eats up most, if not all, of Kearns’ salary for next year (last year of his contract). Kearns is
owed $8 million next year, about six million more than he is worth.
the Nationals are willing to pay that six million, then it makes sense for the
Phillies, with their need of right-handed outfielders, to acquire Kearns as
part of the solution to Burrell leaving.
I am not saying that Kearns is worthy of being the Phillies starting
left fielder. He’s only as good as
a fourth outfielder, but he is a good guy to provide power off the bench, and be a
back-up in case of injury.
team interested in acquiring Kearns (actually Detroit and Toronto are
the others I can think of) should understand they have all the leverage in the
world. The Nationals need to get rid of
Kearns no matter how much salary they have to eat, and no matter how bad a
prospect they get. The Nats have Roger
Milledge, and Elijah Dukes
set to start with Willie Harris,
and Wily Mo
Pena behind them. Kearns doesn’t
deserve to be in AAA, but he has no place with the Nationals.
I said, the Nationals hardly have any leverage even though they have the player
with the bigger name. Therefore they have to
take it easy on their asking price. The
important negotiation process will not be what prospect they get, but rather
how much they will pay of Kearns’ salary.
I think 75% is enough. Obviously
the more money the Nationals eat, the better prospect they get but they can’t
get carried away. Moises
Melendez is not trash. True, he’s
not a high profile prospect (like Kearns once was) and probably projects as
a middle reliever or lefty specialist, but hey, that’s the type of pitcher the
Nats need more of. Melendez wasn’t used
as a lefty specialist this year in Class-A Lakewood, but being a left-handed
middle reliever without dominating stuff makes it a likely future
scenario. Melendez would go to Potomac
(A+), and maybe get a taste of Double-A before the season ends.
matter how much salary they he will have to eat, Jim Bowden (who apparently
thinks he a Jedi)
needs to trade Kearns. End of
story. I hope Jimmy B can put Kearns’ “glory”
years with the Reds behind him, and move on to younger, more talented, less
Rockies trade 1B Joe Koshansky to the Nationals for RHP Saul Rivera
very sad (Saul
is my favorite player), but the truth is, if this deal were made, it would
benefit both teams.
Saul is extremely
nice to fans, but he’s 31 years old entering next season. That’s just slightly too old for the
rebuilding Nationals. Plus, Rivera is a
perfect fit for the Rockies who need bullpen help. After the Holliday deal, they acquired Street, but he will
probably be flipped over to another team.
I also doubt they will pick up Matt Herges‘
option for next year considering his poor season and his age (39). If you add Rivera to the Colorado ‘pen, it
will most likely look like this:
you noticed there were no lefties in the pen.
That’s because the only left-handed reliever the Rockies have right now
Rusch, and he had a 5.30 ERA last year as a reliever, and lefties have a
.334 OBP against him in his career. A
.334 OBP is not bad but to make a team as a lefty specialist, you need to be
better than that.
Todd Helton, Garrett Atkins,
and Jeff Baker
in Colorado, so the Rockies need to trade him.
He has shown enough talent and put up good enough numbers in the minors
to have legitimate trade value. There
will be other teams interested like the Giants and Mariners or maybe even the
Yankees. Ultimately, I think Saul
Rivera will win the Rockies over.
the Nationals have Kory Casto, Nick Johnson,
Willingham. All that doesn’t mean
much though. First off, the Nationals
need to trade away Willingham; he just doesn’t fit with the team. Plus, there is little chance Johnson or
Young can return completely healthy.
And if they are healthy, GM Jim Bowden should trade them for whatever he
can get, and that won’t be much. If
they manage to start next season healthy, they better be traded quickly because
it won’t be long before they go back on the DL.
There is almost as little hope as
Johnson and Young both staying healthy as there is a chance Kory Casto can
finally start producing in the bigs. In
82 career games, he’s had 14 extra base hits and a measly .264 OBP. It’s worth noting that Casto’s horrendous
MLB stint in 2007 really drowned his career numbers, but even though he
improved greatly in 2008, he still wasn’t all that impressive. This last spring I had faith in Casto. I truly thought it was not too late for him
to turn his career around. But now it’s
time to move on and try something else.
That means it is time to finally give Koshansky a full-time major league
Casto can still make the team next year.
After all, he can play left field and both corner positions. Who knows, maybe Casto can capture some of his
minor league power and bring it to the bigs.
Koshansky doesn’t mean Washington is lacking future first base options. Chris
Marrero has dealt with injuries and slumps since he was drafted in the
first round two years ago but he still has big power potential. Bill Rhinehart
doesn’t have the same big upside as Marrero but he put together a good 2008 and
should next year in Double-A Harrisburg.
Nationals trade 2B Ronnie Belliard to the D-Backs for RHP Josh Ellis
me first start off by saying that I don’t think Anderson
Hernandez will ever develop into an adequate starting major league second
baseman. But with the way things are
for the Nationals, they need to at least give him a chance. Despite his AAA .262 OBP he did hit .407
after joining the Nats. He also seems
to have brought his hot bat to the Dominican Winter League as he holds a 1.055 OPS
he is one of the oldest players in the team and needs to be traded this
I’ll give Bowden credit for
signing Belliard. Ronnie was the
starting second baseman for St. Louis when they
won the World Series in 2006.
Weirdly enough (well, he only had a .297 OBP with St. Louis), Belliard
wasn’t signed until February 18th to a minor league contract by the Nats. That was only five days before spring
training started. Belliard has done
everything Washington could have imagined and more. The reality is the only way the Belliard signing can truly help
the Nationals is if Bowden trades him for some prospects. Despite
landing on the DL and missing almost 40% of the season, Belliard’s trade value
absolutely soared this season. Not only
did he have his best offensive season of his career, but also he increased his
versatility by playing both corner positions as well as his natural position at
second. The Mets, Brewers, and Dodgers
may hold some interest in Belliard as well, but Arizona appears to be the best
fit for Belliard and the Nats.
Ojeda didn’t have good enough years to warrant consideration for a
full-time gig at 2B. Jesus Merchan
had a nice year at Triple-A and holds a good spot to take over Chris Burke’s
spot on next year’s 25-man roster. That
will allow Burke to gather up some time at Triple-A at bats after his
Josh Ellis is
the prospect that makes the most sense for this specific deal. The two main needs the Nationals have in
their system are middle infielders and relievers. Since the Arizona system is weak on middle infielders, relief
pitchers are the best way to go. Ellis
had a 2.40 ERA this year in Visalia (A+) in his first professional season.
You can see, he pitches sort of like Brian Shouse or Cla Meredith. Too bad the Diamondbacks are moving their AAA affiliate to Reno
(the Reno Aces) because Ellis could have had a chance to be a sidewinder on the
Tucson Sidewinders. The Diamondbacks
are stocked with young relievers, so if pitchers like Abe Woody, A.J. Shappi, Kyler Newby, Jeff Dietz,
Maine were offered for Belliard, it would be a fair and beneficial trade
Although it is time for Belliard to leave Washington, he will always be remembered becuase of
other baseball news, the iconic Oriole Bird has quit his diet. He has gone from this:
To this (maybe it’s just perspective):
The diet obviously wasn’t working because ever since
the Bird started the diet in 1998, the team is 98 games below .500. Ouch.
They need change. And that
change should come in the form of the logo and mascot getting a beer belly like
Wild Bill Hagy. Thumps up to the Orioles front office. This is their first sign of intelligence since they designed Camden Yards.
TB trades Andy Sonnanstine to NYM; NYM trades SS Reese Havens and CF
Ezequiel Carrera to SF; SF trades Randy Winn, RHP Keiichi Yabu, and LHP Geno
Espineli to TB
So this is a three-team deal.
And yes, the Rays trade away one of their starters in the playoffs Andy
Sonnanstine. Still, this trade
makes sense for every team involved.
The Rays predictably will use their starting pitcher depth to acquire a
bona-fide starter in right field. In
this case it would be Randy Winn.
It’s true, the Rays have a lot of players
who play right field. Eric Hinske, Gabe Gross, Ben Zobrist, Fernando Perez,
Ruggiano all are capable. But
Hinske and Gross are not exactly the type of guys you want starting every day
on a team that is expected to compete for the championship again next
year. Zobrist and Perez are bright,
young players but at least at this point are most valuable being on the bench
because of Perez’s ability to play every OF position, and his blazing
speed. Zobrist also is very versatile
and is a valuable guy off the bench. He
might even have a reasonable chance to overtake Iwamura
as the Rays starting second baseman. Ruggiano
has done everything you could ask from him in AAA. Yet he just can’t seem to bring the same game to the majors. He had a .911 OPS in 66 AAA games versus
.576 with the Rays. So, with Winn
coming up, in it can put all of the right field questions to rest while adding
a veteran presence that can fill the #2 spot in the Rays order. That way Iwamura can move down in the order
where he should be. If Crawford
continues to struggle, Iwamura could easily come back to the top instead of a
guy like Upton having to be taken out of the heart of the order.
Although Winn will obviously make a huge mark on
the Rays, I think Andy Sonnanstine is the biggest impact player involved in
this deal. Simply put, to have a
Sonnanstine in the Mets rotation would be fantastic for them. Even if, at his best, Sonnanstine is only as
good as a #3 starter, his ability to eat up innings without eating payroll is a
quality invaluable to the Mets at this point.
This way the Mets can afford not resigning Oliver Perez. In my opinion, Jon Niese is
ready to be the Mets’ 5th starter next year. However, if the Mets do re-sign Perez their
rotation would be dynamite. Whether or
not Perez comes back, the Mets would have, for the first time in a while, a
young rotation that can last a long time.
To have a rotation where every pitcher in under control until 2012 is a
huge advantage over the other NL East clubs.
Of course since Sonnanstine is that
valuable, New York will have to give up a lot.
The big sacrifice that the Mets will have to make is their second pick
of the 2008 draft, slugging infielder Reese Havens.
Havens (left) was drafted 22nd overall
as a shortstop but is expected to wind up as third or second baseman by the
time he gets to the majors. Ezequiel
Carrera, a High-A outfielder, didn’t put up great numbers this year but if
you start thinking about his age (21) and the fact that he completely skipped
A-ball, his .344 OBP, 28 steals, and seven dingers are pretty impressive. The Giants have a fair amount of outfielders
like Fred Lewis,
Schierholtz and some nice prospects like Antoan
Richardson, Ben Copeland,
Martinez-Esteve. And yet, with the
decent chance that Rowand and Lewis could get traded in the near future,
Copeland’s and Richardson’s non-overwhelmingness, and Martinez-Esteve’s and
Schierholtz’s sudden lack of power, there is a reason to why the Giants might
want to add another outfield prospect.
Now when you think about it, Tampa Bay would be
trading Sonnanstine straight up for Winn, and that obviously wouldn’t favor
them. But if you add Yabu and Espineli to
the deal, it evens out. Those two will
add depth to the bullpen. And although
Espineli (right) probably will find himself spending some time in Durham, he provides a
lefty arm and the credentials of 2.66 in Triple-A last year in the hitter-friendly
Pacific Coast League. Yabu (below) is pretty old but if he can be effective when he’s 40 (3.57 ERA), how much much worse can he be at 41?
SO, when it’s all said and done, here’s how it
would work out for each team:
Receive Give Up
Randy Winn Andy Sonnanstine
Receive Give Up
Reese Havens Randy Winn
Ezequiel Carrera Keiichi
Receive Give Up
Andy Sonnanstine Reese
So, what do you think? Fair all around?
I guess since Monday marks the beginning of
baseball’s hardware week, I will give you my picks for each major award (with the
runner-up in parentheses):
Again, these are my picks for who deserves each
award, not my predictions for who will win:
Rookie of the Year
AL – Evan Longoria — (Jose Arredondo)
NL – Geovany Soto — (Joey Votto)
AL – Cliff Lee — (Roy Halladay)
NL – Johan Santana — (CC Sabathia)
AL – Kevin Youkilis — (Mark Teixeira)
NL – Wily Mo Pe, I
mean, Albert Pujols — (Manny
Manager of the Year
AL – Joe Maddon — (Ron Gardenhire)
NL – Cecil Cooper — (Charlie Manuel)
Often I ask myself “Who is the worst GM in baseball” Well, in my mind, it is a pretty easy answer. The worst GM in baseball currently is Brian Sabean. The Giants are just in a horrible situation with a bunch of veterans making big money, and a drained out farm system. Basically, the only youth on the Giants is Tim Lincecum, Matt Cain, Jonathan Sanchez, Manny Burriss, Brian Wilson, and Fred Lewis. There’s a lot of talent in there, but as a whole, the Giants franchise is a mess. It all is Sabean’s fault becasue he signed so many old veterans to huge contracts like Omar Vizquel, Edgar Alfonzo, Ryan Klesko, Aaron Rowand and so on and so on. The Giants at one point had an all 40+ outfield. Steve Finley, Barry Bonds, and Moises Alou. So after Finley and Alou left, guess who replaces them? More veterans: Dave Roberts and Randy Winn. Then once Roberts left, Sabean signs Rowand to an outrageous contract spanning five years. Rowand will be 36 years old at the end of the contract.
Sabean continuously lost top draft picks for signing signing free agents. Because of Sabean, the Giants didn’t even have a pick in the first round in 2004 or 2005. Here are the Giants top draft picks since Sabean was named GM along with the overall number they were drafted at. Yes, that 132 next to Ben Copeland’s name is not a typo. The first player drafted by Giants was the 132nd overall in the fourth round. Was signing Michael Tucker as a free agent worth giving up a first round draft pick?
1997: Jason Grilli – 4
1998: Tony Torcato – 19
1999: Kurt Ainsworth – 24
2000: Boof Bonser – 21
2001: Brad Hennessey – 21
2002: Matt Cain – 25
2003: David Aardsma – 22
2004: Eddy Martinez-Esteve – 70
2005: Ben Copeland – 132
2006: Tim Lincecum – 10
2007: Madison Bumgarner – 10
2008: Buster Posey – 5
Most people know about how Sabean traded away Francisco Liriano, Boof Bonser, and Joe Nathan to acquire A.J. Pierzynski. No other trade could be as bad as that, but here are some more awful trades made by Sabean. Click on their names to see their stats, but more importantly, to see how little of Sabean’s acquisitions made an impact in San Francisco.
- July 31st 1997 – Sent Livan Hernandez and Edwards Guzman to the Expos for Jim Brower and Matt Blank – Brower was a valuable piece of the Giants bullpen in 03 and 04, but you don’t trade a middle reliever for a top of the rotation starter in his prime.
- July 29th 2001 – Sent Alan Embree to White Sox for Derek Hasselhoff– You can understand the Giants wanting to get rid of Embree in 2001, but boy did it turn out horribly for the Giants.
- December 17th 2002 – Sent Russ Ortiz to the Braves for Damian Moss and Merkin Valdez – Ortiz won 36 games in his two years with Braves, while Moss did nothing for the Giants. Valdez could be a good reliever for the Giants but I doubt he will ever win 21 games.
- November 14th 2003 – Sent Francisco Liriano, Boof Bonser, and Joe Nathan to the Twins for A.J. Pierzynski – Oh boy, Oh Boy. Sabean will never get over this, and another bad part about this move is, not only did the Giants get ripped off in talent but they also got ripped off in money. Pierzynski enjoyed the worst year in his career in his only year in SF. He made 3 and a half million that year too.
- July 22nd 2006 – Sent Jeremy Accardo to the Blue Jays for Shea Hillenbrand and Vinnie Chulk – Chulk was an OK middle man for the Giants but Jeremy Accardo is a future closer, and destined to be better then Brian Wilson.
Although Sabean is the worst general manager currently in baseball, I have to say the worst general manager that I have lived through is Jim Duquette. Duquette always said the right things: “We need to get younger”, “we take advantage of the newest statistical breakthroughs like VORP, and RCPG”. Duquette seems like he’s smart, but he never makes any good decisions, and also signs a whole lot of veterans as free agents. Duquette was the Mets general manager in 2004, and the Orioles’s GM in 2005 and 2006. Well, most of the Mets nowadays is comprised of players that Omar Minaya acquired or signed. Duquette made a large impact on the Orioles, and well, look at the Orioles now. MacPhail has done a pretty good job since replacing Duquette, but it will take a *long* time to get the Orioles to the Red Sox or Rays level.
He was the assistant GM for Steve Phillips from 1998 to when Phillips was fired. Shortly after Phillips left, Duquette criticized Phillips for the job he did. Frankly, I’ll agree with anybody who criticizes Steve Phillips, but Jim, YOU were his assistant so you can’t be talking. Duquette made many bad deals when he was with the Mets and Orioles. Here are some …..
- October 3rd 2003 – Announced Marcos Scutaro had been claimed off waivers by the A’s – I’m not saying Marco Scutaro can make a wild card card team a pennant team, but with all the second base questions for the Mets the past couple years it would have been nice to have Marcos. What did Jim and the Mets get? Nothing.
- June 17th 2004 – Sent Jeremy Griffiths and Dave Weathers to the Astros for Richard Hidalgo – Hidalgo did nothing but make money, while Weathers became the reliever the Mets needed so badly the past three years.
- July 30th 2004 – Sent Scott Kazmir and Joselo Diaz to the Devil Rays for Victor Zambrano and Bartolome Fortunato – You can’t call yourself a baseball fan if you need me to tell you how bad this trade was. Imagine the top of the Mets rotation being Johan, Kazmir, and Maine. Heck, the Devil Rays even got the better of the two extra players. To make Duquette even stupider this is a direct quote from Jim after he had made the trade and signed Kris Benson as a free agent:
“We’re getting younger and transforming our
roster that a year ago or two years ago was one of the oldest in
baseball. Both of these
pitchers are 29 years old, they still have a lot of mileage ahead of them,
pitching-wise.” So to make a team younger, you trade away prospects?
- August 27th 2004 – Sent Dan Wheeler to the Astros for Adam Seuss – Wheeler and Weathers would be huge in a shaky Mets bullpen, but at least we got Adam Seuss. Yay.
Now it’s time for the deals Duquette made after Peter Angelos hired him to run the Orioles. That Angelos is a smart one. That must be why Orioles fan are staging protests outside Camden Yards.
- December 13th 2005 – Orioles Sign Ramon Hernandez to a $27.5 million contract over four years – Hernandez’s contract is probably already labeled a failure no matter how good he does in the last year of his contract. Hernandez is impossible to trade at this point and never really helped the O’s
- January 9th 2006 – Sent Nate Spears and Carlos Perez to the Cubs for Corey Patterson – I wouldn’t blame you if you don’t recognize the names of the players the Cubs got for Patterson, but you may soon. Patterson has been atrocious for the Orioles and now the Reds, and has still not been able to shake the habit of trying to hit a home run every time.
- January 22nd 2006 – Sent John Maine and Jorge Julio to the Mets for Kris Benson – For some reason, Duquette loves Benson, and is taken him everywhere he goes. Although I don’t like Maine as a person, he’s pretty good when it comes to throwing a baseball.
- June 25th 2006 – Signed Russ Ortiz to a one year deal – The numbers don’t lie, the numbers don’t lie.
- November 27th 2006 – Signed Danys Baez to 3-Year Contract worth over $18 million – This deal was doomed from the start, Baez was never that great, and was injury prone. The worst part is that the Orioles are still forced to pay him for another year.
Duquette has also been extremely unsuccessful in drafts. He has only had the opportunity to pick in 2004, 2005, and 2006, but he screwed up on every first pick in those years. Here are his drafts picks:
2004: Phil Humber – 3rd Overall – 2008 Stats
Level G GS ERA W L IP H BB SO
AAA 22 15 5.92 4 7 79 95 37 54
Other Players Duquette Could Have Drafted:
2005: Brandon Snyder – 13th Overall – 2008 Stats
Level G AB H .OBP HR RBI SB BB SO .SLG
A+ 74 274 83 .334 7 46 2 12 49 .478
Other Players Duquette Could Have Drafted:
2006: Billy Rowell – 9th Overall – 2008 Stats
Level G AB H .OBP HR RBI SB BB SO .SLG
A+ 70 236 53 .292 3 33 0 22 65 .347
Other Players Duquette Could Have Drafted:
A sign of a bad GM is a guy that is unwilling to rebuild. A GM’s goal shouldn’t be to get to .500 and spend money and prospects to do it. A GM’s goal should be to win the World Series and create a dynasty to last for years. To create a dynasty, a GM must build from within and end up having a great and large group of talented core players. If you look at any dynasty in baseball history, 70’s Pirates, late 90’s Yankees, 70’s Reds, early millennium M’s, they all had a large group of players just entering their primes. Those teams had those players throughout the whole prime of their careers.
All teams that have had streaks of losing
seasons have had GM’s that were unwilling to rebuild. I’m not talking about bad teams like the Astros or Padres right now. I’m talking about teams like the Orioles, Pirates, and Reds. Somewhere along the way, these teams have had bad GM’s that chose not to rebuild and that is the reason why not any of these teams have made the playoffs in 14 seasons.
Well, mlb.com, you should not let people think Jim Duquette is a good guy to inform you on key information. Assuming that mlb.com is filmed in New York City though, Duquette should be careful walking around Queens or Brooklyn. I sense St. Petersburg would be a good place for Duquette to retire.
I found this awesome video on YouTube. Check it out.