This was a blockbuster
trade that I never got to officially analyze, so here we go…
I don’t know why the
Rockies asked for Carlos Gonzalez because they already had a logjam in the
outfield without him. I also don’t know
why the Athletics targeted Greg Smith rather than another young A’s pitcher who
doesn’t give up a lot of fly balls, which does not bode well for Coors
Field. It still made sense for Colorado
to trade Holliday because they got enough talent back for the trade to work,
but I’m not convinced the Rockies were bad enough to give him up. With Holliday, I suspected the Rockies would
have a reasonable shot to win the NL West because remember, in the land of
losers, the .500 team is king.
I guess Dan
O’Dowd didn’t want to take the risk of keeping Holliday until July where he
would have had half the package the A’s offered for a full season of Holliday’s
services. The funny thing is that I
assumed the A’s and Rockies would have about the same amount of success next
season. This is just a trade based off
the GMs’ decisions. Billy
Beane decided his team was good enough to win the World Series if they
acquired Holliday (and perhaps another FA), and chose to go all out. I cannot disagree with him. The A’s have a ton of young starters, and a
bevy of position players who could break out like Kurt Suzuki, Daric Barton,
Cunningham. The ladder would have
most likely been the starting 2009 left fielder if Holliday was never
acquired. But with only 20 games in
Triple-A under his belt, Cunningham probably is best suited to take over Holliday’s
spot in 2010.
Dan O’Dowd made the choice
to build for the future and basically sacrifice 2009. I cannot argue with that decision either because the Rockies are
an extremely young team whose best years are in front of them. 2010 and 2011 will most likely go very well
for Colorado due to them having a lush farm system full of high ceiling
However, I do question why O’Dowd asked for Carlos Gonzalez from the A’s when he could have
asked for relief help instead. I’m not
saying the A’s would have given up their top relief prospect in Andrew
Carignan, but the Rockies could have improved upon their poor bullpen depth by asking for a couple of relief prospects like Lance Sewell
(left) and Sam Demel (right).
The Rockies just don’t
need more outfielders. Brad Hawpe is
a lock in right, Ryan
Spilborghs should be a lock in center, and Seth Smith is
good to go in right. Smith killed the
ball in Triple-A the past two years and deserves a chance to play everyday in
Colorado. At the very least he can be
an inexpensive stopgap in left field until Dexter Fowler
or Eric Young
Jr. are ready.
If Gonzalez is flipped to
another team in return for more prospects, this deal could wind up being an
extremely good one for the Rockies. But
until that deal is made, I’m not sure Dan O’Dowd did the best job he could have
in trading away the face of the franchise.
This trade makes sense for
both teams, but I’m not convinced Dan O’Dowd chose the right players from
Oakland. Nor am I completely convinced
the A’s are going to be good enough to make the playoffs next year.
Athletics – B+
Rockies – B+
Nationals trade Austin Kearns to the Phillies for LHP Moises Melendez
a lot of “ifs” in this trade. This deal
only makes sense if the Phillies fail to re-sign Pat Burrell, and if
Washington eats up most, if not all, of Kearns’ salary for next year (last year of his contract). Kearns is
owed $8 million next year, about six million more than he is worth.
the Nationals are willing to pay that six million, then it makes sense for the
Phillies, with their need of right-handed outfielders, to acquire Kearns as
part of the solution to Burrell leaving.
I am not saying that Kearns is worthy of being the Phillies starting
left fielder. He’s only as good as
a fourth outfielder, but he is a good guy to provide power off the bench, and be a
back-up in case of injury.
team interested in acquiring Kearns (actually Detroit and Toronto are
the others I can think of) should understand they have all the leverage in the
world. The Nationals need to get rid of
Kearns no matter how much salary they have to eat, and no matter how bad a
prospect they get. The Nats have Roger
Milledge, and Elijah Dukes
set to start with Willie Harris,
and Wily Mo
Pena behind them. Kearns doesn’t
deserve to be in AAA, but he has no place with the Nationals.
I said, the Nationals hardly have any leverage even though they have the player
with the bigger name. Therefore they have to
take it easy on their asking price. The
important negotiation process will not be what prospect they get, but rather
how much they will pay of Kearns’ salary.
I think 75% is enough. Obviously
the more money the Nationals eat, the better prospect they get but they can’t
get carried away. Moises
Melendez is not trash. True, he’s
not a high profile prospect (like Kearns once was) and probably projects as
a middle reliever or lefty specialist, but hey, that’s the type of pitcher the
Nats need more of. Melendez wasn’t used
as a lefty specialist this year in Class-A Lakewood, but being a left-handed
middle reliever without dominating stuff makes it a likely future
scenario. Melendez would go to Potomac
(A+), and maybe get a taste of Double-A before the season ends.
matter how much salary they he will have to eat, Jim Bowden (who apparently
thinks he a Jedi)
needs to trade Kearns. End of
story. I hope Jimmy B can put Kearns’ “glory”
years with the Reds behind him, and move on to younger, more talented, less
Rockies trade 1B Joe Koshansky to the Nationals for RHP Saul Rivera
very sad (Saul
is my favorite player), but the truth is, if this deal were made, it would
benefit both teams.
Saul is extremely
nice to fans, but he’s 31 years old entering next season. That’s just slightly too old for the
rebuilding Nationals. Plus, Rivera is a
perfect fit for the Rockies who need bullpen help. After the Holliday deal, they acquired Street, but he will
probably be flipped over to another team.
I also doubt they will pick up Matt Herges‘
option for next year considering his poor season and his age (39). If you add Rivera to the Colorado ‘pen, it
will most likely look like this:
you noticed there were no lefties in the pen.
That’s because the only left-handed reliever the Rockies have right now
Rusch, and he had a 5.30 ERA last year as a reliever, and lefties have a
.334 OBP against him in his career. A
.334 OBP is not bad but to make a team as a lefty specialist, you need to be
better than that.
Todd Helton, Garrett Atkins,
and Jeff Baker
in Colorado, so the Rockies need to trade him.
He has shown enough talent and put up good enough numbers in the minors
to have legitimate trade value. There
will be other teams interested like the Giants and Mariners or maybe even the
Yankees. Ultimately, I think Saul
Rivera will win the Rockies over.
the Nationals have Kory Casto, Nick Johnson,
Willingham. All that doesn’t mean
much though. First off, the Nationals
need to trade away Willingham; he just doesn’t fit with the team. Plus, there is little chance Johnson or
Young can return completely healthy.
And if they are healthy, GM Jim Bowden should trade them for whatever he
can get, and that won’t be much. If
they manage to start next season healthy, they better be traded quickly because
it won’t be long before they go back on the DL.
There is almost as little hope as
Johnson and Young both staying healthy as there is a chance Kory Casto can
finally start producing in the bigs. In
82 career games, he’s had 14 extra base hits and a measly .264 OBP. It’s worth noting that Casto’s horrendous
MLB stint in 2007 really drowned his career numbers, but even though he
improved greatly in 2008, he still wasn’t all that impressive. This last spring I had faith in Casto. I truly thought it was not too late for him
to turn his career around. But now it’s
time to move on and try something else.
That means it is time to finally give Koshansky a full-time major league
Casto can still make the team next year.
After all, he can play left field and both corner positions. Who knows, maybe Casto can capture some of his
minor league power and bring it to the bigs.
Koshansky doesn’t mean Washington is lacking future first base options. Chris
Marrero has dealt with injuries and slumps since he was drafted in the
first round two years ago but he still has big power potential. Bill Rhinehart
doesn’t have the same big upside as Marrero but he put together a good 2008 and
should next year in Double-A Harrisburg.
Nationals trade 2B Ronnie Belliard to the D-Backs for RHP Josh Ellis
me first start off by saying that I don’t think Anderson
Hernandez will ever develop into an adequate starting major league second
baseman. But with the way things are
for the Nationals, they need to at least give him a chance. Despite his AAA .262 OBP he did hit .407
after joining the Nats. He also seems
to have brought his hot bat to the Dominican Winter League as he holds a 1.055 OPS
he is one of the oldest players in the team and needs to be traded this
I’ll give Bowden credit for
signing Belliard. Ronnie was the
starting second baseman for St. Louis when they
won the World Series in 2006.
Weirdly enough (well, he only had a .297 OBP with St. Louis), Belliard
wasn’t signed until February 18th to a minor league contract by the Nats. That was only five days before spring
training started. Belliard has done
everything Washington could have imagined and more. The reality is the only way the Belliard signing can truly help
the Nationals is if Bowden trades him for some prospects. Despite
landing on the DL and missing almost 40% of the season, Belliard’s trade value
absolutely soared this season. Not only
did he have his best offensive season of his career, but also he increased his
versatility by playing both corner positions as well as his natural position at
second. The Mets, Brewers, and Dodgers
may hold some interest in Belliard as well, but Arizona appears to be the best
fit for Belliard and the Nats.
Ojeda didn’t have good enough years to warrant consideration for a
full-time gig at 2B. Jesus Merchan
had a nice year at Triple-A and holds a good spot to take over Chris Burke’s
spot on next year’s 25-man roster. That
will allow Burke to gather up some time at Triple-A at bats after his
Josh Ellis is
the prospect that makes the most sense for this specific deal. The two main needs the Nationals have in
their system are middle infielders and relievers. Since the Arizona system is weak on middle infielders, relief
pitchers are the best way to go. Ellis
had a 2.40 ERA this year in Visalia (A+) in his first professional season.
You can see, he pitches sort of like Brian Shouse or Cla Meredith. Too bad the Diamondbacks are moving their AAA affiliate to Reno
(the Reno Aces) because Ellis could have had a chance to be a sidewinder on the
Tucson Sidewinders. The Diamondbacks
are stocked with young relievers, so if pitchers like Abe Woody, A.J. Shappi, Kyler Newby, Jeff Dietz,
Maine were offered for Belliard, it would be a fair and beneficial trade
Although it is time for Belliard to leave Washington, he will always be remembered becuase of
other baseball news, the iconic Oriole Bird has quit his diet. He has gone from this:
To this (maybe it’s just perspective):
The diet obviously wasn’t working because ever since
the Bird started the diet in 1998, the team is 98 games below .500. Ouch.
They need change. And that
change should come in the form of the logo and mascot getting a beer belly like
Wild Bill Hagy. Thumps up to the Orioles front office. This is their first sign of intelligence since they designed Camden Yards.
With the treading deadline coming, and rumors swirling, I’ve
just put together some trades that could make sense for both teams, or maybe
what a team should ask for a specific player on the block. Take Brian
Fuentes for example. I think the Rockies need to trade him.
The Rox need pitching too much to beat out the D-Backs or Dodgers for the NL
West. The Rays have so many young pitchers in their system, that’s a
great match for the Rockies and Rays to trade with each other.
Rays, seriously, are absolutely stocked with young pitching. I know the
saying “you can never have enough pitching” but if the
Rays want another player, they can afford to give up a pitcher. Brian
Fuentes can make any bullpen a lot better, and for the Rays, the boost would be
huge. The Rays have SO many young starting pitchers: Scott Kazmir, Andy
Sonnanstine, Edwin Jackson, James Shields, Jeff Niemann, David Price,
Chris Mason, Wade Davis, Jeremy Hellickson, and Jacob McGee. If the
Rays would never trade any of these pitchers, there would be some talented pitchers
not in the Rays rotation.
That where the Rockies come in. If
Chris Mason wasn’t having such a bad year in Durham, I’d propose a Mason for
Fuentes trade, straight up. But Mason’s value is greatly diminished, so I
think the Rockies should focus on Jeff Niemann(pictured).
In no way am I saying
that Niemann is a better prospect than Wade Davis, David Price, Jeremy
Hellickson, or Jacob McGee, but all of the names I just mentioned are not worth
giving up for just Brian Fuentes. Niemann seems right. He’s a big
guy, 6’10, who has been hampered by injuries early in his career, but over the
past two seasons at AAA he’s been healthy. He’s expendable for the Rays,
but would be considered a large part of the future of the Rockies
rotation. I had Niemann down to make the Rays rotation this spring over
Edwin Jackson and Jason Hammel. Jackson has done a fairly good job this year, so
I’ve been proven wrong, but Niemann is probably ready for the Majors now.
OK, so here is the list of trades I would make if I were the
GM of the Rockies, Rays or Nationals.
Brian Fuentes for Jeff Niemann
Tim Redding for Nick Stavinhoa and Mitchell Boggs
Odalis Perez Tyler Herron, Jaret Hoffpauier, and
Skip Schumaker and Daryl Jones
(Many different combinations involving these Cardinal prospects could be used, but these combos seem evenly balanced.)
Christian Guzman for James
Victor Garate, and Ivan De Jesus
Adolfo Gonzalez, Chin-lung Hu, and
It may be a stretch to say the Nationals could get McDonald
for letting the Dodgers rent Guzman for half a year.
McDonald(pictured) is the best Dodgers pitching prospect behind Clayton Kershaw,
and most likely will hold that title after this year. But because the N.L. West is so open for any team to break out,
the Dodgers may feel they need Guzman (which they do), so if the Nationals
could capitalize on the N.L. West situation and get a pitcher like James
McDonald that would be huge for the Nats future.
The Nationals also need some middle
infield prospects, so Hu, Gonzalez and De Jesus could be huge assets. The only legitimate
middle infield prospect in the Nats system is Esmailyn “Smilin” Gonzalez and he
is 18 years old playing in rookie ball. Who will play shortstop if Guzman goes? Either Pete Orr(I’m fine with that), or Yurendell De Caster. De Caster has been good in Columbus and deserves a first shot at the bigs.
Speaking of the Nationals, why do they have four catchers?
They just placed Wily Mo Pena on the DL, and reinstated Johnny Estrada to the
active roster. That means they have
Jesus Flores, Wil Nieves, Paul Lo Duca, and Johnny Estrada: all catchers. I’m fine with a team having three catchers
as long as one of them is can play other positions. But four!? I mean, Lo
Duca can play left, and first base, I suppose, but he plays below average in
all of those positions, including catcher.
Estrada has no upside whatsoever in my mind. He has no power, no speed and is a very below average
defender. I have no idea why the
Nationals didn’t do the sensible thing and call up an outfielder, since they
just put one on the DL. Just call up
Mike Daniel! I already talked about the
whole situation in this post. https://mlblogsdistrictboy.files.wordpress.com/2008/07/nelsoncruz-thumb-274×4111.jpgarchives/2008/07/the_nationals_report_part_2.html
On the Blanton deal, I like how Outman(awesome name!) and Cardenas look for
the future, but the Phillies really needed someone like Blanton in their
rotation and they finally realized that if you are going to be a
championship team, Adam Eaton isn’t in your rotation. One question I have is about Josh Outman. The Phillies were grooming him as a reliever
when the trade occurred.
I really don’t know why Outman(pictured above) stopped starting. His career was progressing very smoothly and
he ended the season with a successful call-up to AA. But after five starts in AA this year, the Phillies moved Outman to the
bullpen. His five starts were good and
he didn’t have trouble giving Reading innings but I guess the Phillies thought
in the long run Outman would be better as a reliever. I’ll just let you see the numbers for yourself. I just don’t get it. Here are Outman’s stats.
How bout some more random thoughts? How about the job Eric Stults
has done since being moved to the rotation?
It shows that not everyone is better suited as a reliever.
And lastly, a little chatter from the farm. I have attended some minor league games
recently and David Hernandez of the Baysox looked dominant. I’ll be keeping an eye on his career, but
the last minor leaguer who I followed after being impressed at a game hasn’t been
doing so well, Rodolfo Encarnacion.
Collin Cowgill has cooled down since being promoted to Class
A South Bend(ARI) and Mike Loree(SF) has, for one start, not been pitching like
Superman. Loree truly was incredible
and now matter what he does in his career, he already is guaranteed as the
topic for a “Cracked Bats” article in seventy years. Whenever I talk about the minors in general I have to give a
shout-out to my favorite MILB team. GO
I know this was a really messy blog topic-wise but hey, that what the title said – “Notes, Thoughts, and Trades”
P.S. Doesn’t seem
like a crime that Terry Tiffee, Brian Myrow(now a back-up in SD), John Lindsey, and Nelson Cruz are
still in AAA? Especially Nelson
Cruz. Those are SICK, SICK, SICK
numbers. Oh please Jon Daniels, trade
him to a team that isn’t stocked with outfielders. Anywhere. San Diego. Perfect.
Cruz to San Diego for some pitcher.
Jeez I don’t know maybe Enrique Gonzalez? It probably won’t happen.
Silly me. I’m just a dumb kid
who thought Texas could use some pitching….
“Stuck in Oklahoma”